Wednesday, February 17, 2010

All yee, all yee in Free (Part 2)

In Monday’s, first piece of this blog, I established why—in my opinion—the Congress has already created a very efficient and fair secondary mortgage market, around the services of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac-- and why, following some regulatory changes to their capital structure, portfolio limits, and slight mission change, the two could help resurrect the nation’s conventional mortgage market, far smoother and far faster than anything totally new which Congress could create in the next few years.

It’s an uphill slog convincing the Congress of this because of all of the misinformation about what happened in 2007 and 2008 to the GSEs, but it’s a case that Congress needs to hear and understand.

I also argued that the GSE regulatory regime needs remodled, primarily with new personnel. The Federal Housing Finance Agency (FHFA and its predecessor OFHEO) never has been subject to this kind of efficiency audit and needs to be if Congress wants it to do the job of properly overseeing Fannie and Freddie or something new created by statute.


I ended the Monday segment asking observers to look at the years 2002-2007 as the best and worst of the GSEs and using that microcosm, decide what mortgage market changes were necessary.

Let me short hand those years for you and point out some major issues.

Fannie and Freddie didn’t create themselves. They were designed by Congress (with that model being extended by Democrat and Republican Congresses and Administrations for over 35 years) to fund their own operations, employing private market discipline as made and to provide a secondary mortgage market for low moderate and middle income families, meaning buy mortgage loans from banks, thrifts, mortgage companies and other primary market lenders, which served that demographic.


Until the 1992 law which created the new “risk based capital” rules and OFHEO, HUD oversaw (and has for the past 18 years) achievement of the company's "housing goals," most of which now have been relaxed in with the GSEs in "conservatorship."


Before the 1992 statute, 30% of the GSE business had to serve that group, and then the bill made that 40% with HUD given authority to increase it. Andrew Cuomo, Bill Clinton's HUD Secretary and current NY Attorney General, pressured Fannie and Freddie to do “more” and gradually raised that number so that a whopping 55% of their business volumes had to serve “goals business.”

George W. Bush did his share, too, to try and shackle Fannie and Freddie when his HUD Secretary dramatically shrunk which financed units could be counted towards those goals.


But the key point is that all of the low and moderate income mortgage finance did not financially injure the GSEs. The low-mod, housing loans performed almost as well as the remainder of Fannie's business, which served a higher income cohort but which still fit the low-mod mission obligation.

(Question for the Congress? What conventional lenders—under the law--are responsible for lending to low and moderate income families and people of color, refinancing them, or restructuring their bad loans? Now that Fannie’s and Freddie’s goals have been relaxed and the two companies hobbled, the large commercial banks and their subsidiaries haven’t stepped in, which mean those folks aren’t being supported. See this past Sunday’s Washington Post front page. Link follows.)

(http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-yn/content/article/2010/02/13/AR2010021303745.html?hpid=topnews)



Wall Street Brings Bad Times for the GSEs and the World

In the early years of this decade, Wall Street got directly into the mortgage origination business--in a major way--competing with the GSEs. The “Street firms” (large investment banking houses and commercial banks) figured they could make more money by excluding Fannie and Freddie and their proven underwriting technology and systems, so Wall Street employed an army of mortgage brokers who wrote mortgage applications for thousands who never would have qualified under the GSE system. But the brokers got paid for every loan they produced, so quantity, not quality, became their imperative.



The Street investment banking firms wrested from the GSEs a large segment of the mortgage market, turning those loans into "Private Label Securities" (PLS), broke those bonds into hundreds of component boutique pieces, selling them to institutional investors throughout the world.


What brought the GSEs down was an elixir that they didn't invent or invite, yet it was a drink which they supped heavily. The business mistakes that Fannie and Freddie made were decisions by their former CEOs (Dan Mudd and Dick Syron--worried about losing market share and revenue to Wall Street--to buy those doomed and poorly underwritten, high yielding PLS securities for their mortgage portfolios.

They were a financial time bomb.


It wasn't the GSE structure or low-mod housing mission which brought them down, but it was acquiring the toxic "subprime" assets--the very name of which indicates their below market quality--compared to the traditional Fannie and Freddie purchase of "prime" loans. The PLS subprime mortgage loans were so poorly underwritten by the Street's brokers that the slightest economic downturn started an avalanche of missed payments and ultimate defaults, which swamped the originating guarantors and their PLS investors, some of the strongest financial names in the world.

Low Income Loans Didn’t Burn Fannie and Freddie


Look closely. Very little of the “prime” mortgages and securities owned by the GSEs went bad. Very much of the PLS subprime did and still loses money.


Congress shouldn’t waste time arguing about the low-mod mission. Nothing about it was unreasonable, except the overly large percentage of business demanded, which is why I suggest trimming it by 20% or so, not doing away with it.

Fannie and Freddie showed that obligatory low-income mortgage lending can be done and was done, quite efficiently. The GOP will howl and insist helping the poor was part of the GSE problem. It wasn't and they shouldn't be given standing with that corrosive rhetoric.


Severe individual sanctions were meted out to the former GSE officials who made the colossally poor PLS purchase decisions. Fannie's and Freddie's common stock fell the $60's to about a dollar, where it sits today, crushing their investors. Other GSE employees were fired, embarrassingly and publicly, and some hounded from jobs, with their reputations damaged, income and benefits all lost.


But previous managerial failings and human shortcomings at Fannie and Freddie shouldn't cause Congress to ignore the nation's primary and secondary mortgage system's strong points.


I've suggested a way that Congress and the Administration can responsibly rebuild the nation's mortgage finance system and avoid making themselves subject of ridicule or even voter hostility for laboring long, angrily, and producing a nothing burger.


I hope someone is listening on the Hill and downtown.


Maloni, 2-17-2010


(Here’s a strong piece by Paul Jackson, in Housing Wire, that was sent to me just after I posted Part 1 of this blog.)
http://www.housingwire.com/2010/02/15/plan-b-for-the-gses-there-might-not-even-be-a-plan-a/

36 comments:

單存 said...

以簡單的行為愉悅他人的心靈,勝過千人低頭禱告。 ..................................................

Bill Maloni said...

Those FHFA guys have no sense of humor!

And, they are taking their lives in their hands, saying that stuff about Barney!

Seriously, I'd love to know what the "scammers" are saying/selling, if anyone out there reads the language??

Anonymous said...

Your blog keeps getting better and better! Your older articles are not as good as newer ones you have a lot more creativity and originality now. Keep it up!
And according to this article, I totally agree with your opinion, but only this time! :)

Bill Maloni said...

Must be the my age and the "fine wine" analogy!

I guess I appreciate knowing that I wasn't very good back then, especially since you enjoy the newer stuff.

Don't try those compliments on your spouse/girlfriend/boyfriend.

Anonymous said...

You have to express more your opinion to attract more readers, because just a video or plain text without any personal approach is not that valuable. But it is just form my point of view

Bill Maloni said...

Yo might be surprised at the number of people who think I am too opininated and nto objective.

Maybe the goal is to express my opinion on a wider variety of subjects.

競馬予想 said...

2010 競馬予想 各厩舎・調教師から届けられる最強の馬券情報を限定公開!本物の オッズ 表はコレだ

友達 said...

変わってるって言われるけどわりといい人だよ(笑)!!お笑い好きな人だったら話盛り上がりそうだねO(≧▽≦)O 色んなことに興味深々でおっちょこちょいだからそばで支えてくれる人募集中σ(゜-^*)自分の年齢的に年下の男の子はアウトだからごめんね(*_ _)人 u-3-ummm52@docomo.ne.jp

スタービーチ said...

【緊急】突如として消えたスタービーチが復活!長い年月をかけて不死鳥の如く蘇ったスタビをお楽しみください【緊急】

皐月賞 said...

皐月賞・競馬予想!各厩舎・調教師から届けられる最強の馬券情報を限定公開!本物のオッズ表はコレだ

モバげー said...

モバげーとスタビ、異性とのであいを探すならやはりこの2つのサイトは外せない。Mixiよりも遊べるサイトで楽しもう

セフレ said...

セフレ掲示板で大人の恋愛をしてみませんか?割り切ったセフレと快楽のみを求めた恋愛をしてくださいませ

出会い said...

数多くある出会い系の中でも簡単に出会えるのはココ!女の子の登録人数が多いのであなたの地域のカワイイ娘もゲット出来ちゃうんです

スタービーチ said...

新しくリニューアルオープンしたスタービーチでは、新しいであいのカタチを提案します☆日本で一番有名なであい系、スタビならあなたに出逢いたい人が必ず見つかります

エッチ度チェッカー said...

合コンの必須うアイテムと言えば、エッチ度チェッカーと言うぐらいの知名度です。エッチ度をチェックして、気になる娘と親しくなるチャンスをつかもう。奥手の方でもその日の内にお持ち帰り出来るように、診断結果にはアドバイスも

スタービーチ said...

スタービーチで友達探し!出逢い広場は簡単な無料登録するだけで使い放題でメンバー同士、気軽にメッセージのやり取りが出来るよ!女の子と出逢いのチャンスがあるかも!?詳しくはTOPページにアクセスしてみよう

スタビ said...

いつでもであい放題&即逢いOK!スタビで暇な時間にであいを探そう!!であいが今までなかった人も当サイト、スタービーチなら簡単検索機能であなたの理想の方と出会えちゃう!?簡単登録で今すぐご利用いただけます

スタービーチ said...

スタービーチが完全リニューアルして復活しました!!あの伝説級の出会い系サイトが満を持して再降臨。煌めくような今この瞬間にあなたの胸にもときめきをお届けします

モバゲー said...

モバゲーで探せるご近所掲示板で簡単であい!ゲーム攻略やおススメ小説情報もここでGET!ここでしか見れない裏技も公開中

スタービーチ said...

一時代を築いたスタービーチは閉鎖になってしまいましたが、もう一度楽しい思いをしたい、もう一度遊びたいと思う有志により再度復活しました。本家以上に簡単に会えて楽しい思いを約束します

友達 said...

彼女募集中の人やフリーの人は絶対絡んでください☆ゆきとメールしよ♪ chu-chu-chulip@docomo.ne.jp

モバゲー said...

日本最大、モバゲーより面白いであい系スタービーチがついに復活、進化を遂げた新生スタビをやってみませんか?趣味の合う理想のパートナー探しの手助け、合コンパーティー等も随時開催しています。楽しかった頃のスタビで遊んでみよう

スタービーチ said...

ついに帰ってきたドキドキスタービーチで素敵な恋をGETしよう♪会員数も50万人突破で以前よりも直ぐに理想の相手にであえちゃう!!恋人募集中!!友達仲間を増やしたい方必見!!素敵なであいをお楽しみ下さい☆

ヴィクトリアマイル said...

ヴィクトリアマイル 2010 予想、オッズ、厳選買い目は?今年の波乱をズバリ!確勝買い目公開中!大穴狙いのギャンブラー必見激アツ情報

モバゲー said...

モバゲータウンでであいを求めているなら当サイトへ!当コミュニティサイトは本家のモバゲータウンよりはるかにであいやすい、まさにユーザー様の為のサイトとなっております。であいをお楽しみください

スタービーチ said...

スタービーチから始まる新たな恋をしませんか?スタビ掲示板を利用して新たな恋をしていきましょう

日本ダービー said...

第77回 日本ダービー 2010 予想、オッズ、厳選買い目は?人気が平然と馬券に絡む理由とは!?見事に展開を読んで結果を的中させる

SM度チェッカー said...

最近普通のプレイに物足りなさを感じているそこのアナタ、ワンランク上のプレイをしてみませんか?そんな時の目安にSM度チェッカーを使うんです。自分の深層心理を暴きパートナーとのプレイ時のアドバイスも付きますよ!!一度どうですか

玉の輿度チェッカー said...

世の中手っ取り早く、簡単に金持ちに為ったもん勝ち!!そのためのツールが玉の輿度チェッカーです。心理カウンセラーを雇い、一人一人どうすれば人に好かれるか、最終的に結婚へのプロセスに持っていくかのアドバイスを期間限定で無料サービス中です。上手く玉の輿に乗っければ儲けもんです、一度試してみよう

mコミュ said...

mコミュは無料登録で友達を沢山作る事のできる掲示板サイトです。使った事のない人でも簡単に使う事ができるのでお気軽にお立ち寄りください

スタービーチ said...

スタービーチの出合いは他の出合い系サイトのものよりも確実に良い思いができるのは間違いありません。新しい出合いを求めたいと思っているのなら当サイトを利用してください。損はさせませんよ

mコミュ said...

素敵な出 会 いで愛を育む♪理想の人と楽しめる関係を築きませんか?mコミュでしか味わえない幸せを掴みましょう

スタビ said...

スタビが今一番アツイのはご存じでしょうか?夏休みで出会いを探している娘とすぐに会えちゃうんです。登録無料でここまで出会える所は他には存在しません。今登録して良いパートナーに巡り合おう

gree said...

greeで素敵な時間を過ごしたい・・・そんな願望を叶えてくれるサイト誕生!!今までにないドキドキ感と興奮をこのグリーで楽しみましょう

スタービーチ said...

スタービーチで始まる素敵な出 合いをしていきませんか。楽しめる出 合いを経験するにはココから始まる!!最高の出 合いがあなたを待っている

Anonymous said...

электронные сигареты все модели - курение во общественном месте